Port St. Lucie · Stuart · Compared
Port St. Lucie vs Stuart: prices, taxes, insurance, flood and commute compared.
Short answer. A typical home is valued about the same in both, $384,099 in Port St. Lucie and $374,216 in Stuart (Zillow, September 2026), but the monthly cost differs: Port St. Lucie's 2026 tax rate is 22.0043 mills (proposed) against 17.1323 in the City of Stuart and 15.41 to 15.66 in unincorporated Martin County, and Citizens' average homeowners premium is $3,391 in St. Lucie County against $4,692 in Martin. Our estimate for a $450,000 home with 20% down: about $3,505 a month in Port St. Lucie and $3,373 to $3,393 around Stuart, before HOA, CDD and flood. I'm Brent Sharp, broker and owner: 26 years helping people buy and sell homes here, 12,000+ homes valued, and I work in both counties. Call or text Sharp Real Estate Group LLC at (772) 272-9571.
No winner here: the same lines side by side with dated sources, one $450,000 home run through each tax district with the formula, and which place fits which feature.
Sharp Real Estate Group LLC · Free · No obligation to list · A broker's opinion of value, not an appraisal
Port St. Lucie and Stuart, the numbers
Property Appraisers; Citizens; Zillow; Florida Department of Revenue. Links in Sources.
How do Port St. Lucie and Stuart compare, line by line?
Many "Stuart" addresses sit outside the city limits, in unincorporated Martin County, Sewall's Point or the Martin end of Hutchinson Island. Each row names its source and date.
| Line | Port St. Lucie | Stuart |
|---|---|---|
| County | St. Lucie | Martin (county seat) |
| Population, July 1, 2025 (Census) | 268,062 | 19,451 (Florida's BEBR: 20,573, April 2025) |
| Typical home value, September 2026 (Zillow) | $384,099 | $374,216 |
| Median sale price, all home types, 3 months to September 2026 (Redfin) | $404,807 (-1.3%) | $339,838 (+36.8%, a condo and house mix effect) |
| Median price per square foot (Redfin, same window) | $219 | $223 |
| Single-family median sale, September 2026 (Florida Realtors) | St. Lucie County $395,000 (-1.3%) | Stuart city limits $683K (-2.2%, small sample); Martin County $600,000 |
| Median days to contract, single-family, September 2026 | St. Lucie County 52 | Stuart city limits 34; Martin County 39 |
| Months of supply, single-family, September 2026 | St. Lucie County 5.2 | Stuart city limits 4; Martin County 3.6 |
| 2026 total property tax rate | 22.0043 mills (proposed) | City of Stuart 17.1323; unincorporated Martin 15.41 to 15.66 |
| Flat lines on the tax bill | Solid waste $482.16 and stormwater $195 a year | Unincorporated: solid waste $444.69 (year ending Sept. 2025); City of Stuart: not in our sources |
| Citizens homeowners (HO-3) average, 2026 | $3,391 (St. Lucie County) | $4,692 (Martin County) |
| Citizens condo unit (HO-6) average, 2026 | $1,529 | $1,547 |
| Flood insurance discount (FEMA rating class) | Class 5, 25% | Unincorporated Martin Class 5; City of Stuart not found |
| Hurricane evacuation zones | A and B | AB, CD and E |
| Sales tax, 2026 | 7% | 6.5% |
| Water and sewer | Port St. Lucie Utility Systems (St. Lucie West Services District in St. Lucie West) | City of Stuart Utilities inside the city; Martin County Utilities outside it |
| Septic to sewer conversion | $16,780 for water and sewer, or $138.83 a month for 10 years | Martin County Utilities grinder hookup $10,000, or $8,000 in the first year; City of Stuart grinder share billed over 10 years |
| CDDs | Tradition, Southern Grove and others in newer areas | None identified in downtown Stuart; Newfield in Palm City has one |
| Boat route to the ocean | Most canals have none; tidal North Fork under 65-foot bridges | Under 65-foot fixed spans; no bridge from Manatee Pocket, Port Salerno, Sailfish Point, the Crossroads |
| Interstate access | I-95 Exits 114, 118, 120, 121, 126; Turnpike 138, 142 | I-95 Exits 101, 102, 110; Turnpike 133 |
| Brightline station | None | None (planned station not funded) |
For single-family sale prices the table uses St. Lucie County's official median, because our sources carry no matching Port St. Lucie city figure for September 2026. Redfin's 36.8% for Stuart reflects which homes sold, not a 36.8% rise in value. Zillow is a model, not sale prices.
What does the same $450,000 home cost each month in each place?
Here is one price run through each tax district. It is our estimate, not a loan, tax or insurance quote, and it assumes the assessed value equals the price (in practice it is often lower).
| Monthly line | Port St. Lucie | City of Stuart | Unincorporated Martin County |
|---|---|---|---|
| Principal and interest ($360,000 at 7.11% for 30 years) | $2,422 | $2,422 | $2,422 |
| Property taxes, with homestead, 2026 rates | $745 | $580 | $523 to $531 |
| Flat lines on the tax bill | $56 | Not in our sources | $37 (Sept. 2025 rate) |
| Homeowners insurance (Citizens 2026 county average) | $283 | $391 | $391 |
| Total, with homestead | about $3,505 | about $3,393, plus any city fees | about $3,373 to $3,381 |
| Property taxes without homestead (second home, rental, or before you file) | $825 | $642 | $578 to $587 |
| Total, without homestead | about $3,586 | about $3,455 | about $3,428 to $3,437 |
The formula. Principal and interest: $360,000 at Freddie Mac's 7.11% average for the week of November 12, 2026, over 30 years. Property taxes: school mills x (value minus $25,000) / 1,000, plus the other mills x (value minus $51,411) / 1,000, divided by 12. School mills are 6.2450 in Port St. Lucie and 4.8770 in Martin County, so the other mills are 15.7593 in Port St. Lucie, 12.2553 in the City of Stuart and 10.5375 to 10.7811 in unincorporated Martin. The $51,411 is the 2026 homestead total: $25,000 plus Florida's indexed $26,411. Insurance is the Citizens county average for an HO-3 policy, divided by 12.
What the example leaves out. HOA dues, any CDD (Tradition's operations line alone is $439.51 to $967.80 a year per home in 2026/27), flood insurance, Port St. Lucie street-light lines, Stuart city charges our sources do not list, and the 4% discount for paying the tax bill in November. Port St. Lucie's 22.0043 is a proposed total; only the city's own 4.8750 adoption was confirmed, and adopted rates cannot exceed proposed. Martin's 2026 map is marked "not certified."
2027 and Amendment 3. Florida voters approved Amendment 3 on November 3, 2026 (unofficial results). It raises the non-school homestead exemption to $150,000 in 2027 for owners with a Florida permanent residence by December 31, 2026, and starts newer residents at $50,000. At the same 2026 rates, the tax line on this home would be about $615 a month in Port St. Lucie, $479 in the City of Stuart and $436 to $442 in unincorporated Martin for a qualifying resident, or $746, $581 and $524 to $532 for someone homesteading after moving here in 2027. Local rates for 2027 are not set yet. The rules are in property taxes after you buy on the Treasure Coast.
Why is the tax line so different?
Three reasons. Port St. Lucie's total stacks the city's 4.8750 mills (adopted September 28, 2026) on county, school and fire district levies. Martin County's school rate is lower: 4.8770 against 6.2450. And outside Stuart's city limits there is no city levy at all: the City of Stuart's 17.1323 is the highest total in Martin County, about $830 to $860 a year more on $500,000 of taxable value than a mainland unincorporated address. In St. Lucie County, unincorporated rates (18.8075 to 18.9427 proposed) also run below Port St. Lucie's. Check which district a parcel is in on the St. Lucie County or Martin County Property Appraiser.
How do insurance and flood rules compare?
The state rules are the same in both. Citizens requires flood coverage on every policy with wind coverage from January 1, 2027, even outside flood zones. An insurer cannot refuse or non-renew solely because a roof is under 15 years old. Citizens wants a 4-point inspection on homes more than 20 years old, and sellers in both counties must disclose known flood damage, claims and assistance (s. 689.302).
The local picture differs. Citizens' 2026 average homeowners premium is $1,301 a year lower in St. Lucie County than in Martin. Port St. Lucie and St. Lucie County are Class 5 flood communities (25% off NFIP premiums), as is unincorporated Martin County; a class for the City of Stuart was not found. Look up any address on the FEMA Map Service Center, then read the Treasure Coast home insurance guide.
How do the roads and commute compare?
Both sit on I-95 and Florida's Turnpike. Port St. Lucie has five I-95 interchanges (Exits 114 Becker Road, 118 Gatlin Boulevard and Tradition Parkway, 120 Crosstown Parkway, 121 St. Lucie West Boulevard and 126 Midway Road) and Turnpike Exits 138 and 142; a Midway Road Turnpike interchange is scheduled for construction in the first quarter of 2027. Stuart uses I-95 Exits 101 (Kanner Highway), 102 (High Meadow Avenue) and 110 (Martin Highway), and Martin County's only Turnpike interchange, Exit 133. Neither city has a Brightline station. Test the drive at the hour you would make it.
Which fits if you want a certain feature?
No place wins for everyone. Match the place to the features you want:
- If you want no city tax line: look at unincorporated Martin County (15.41 to 15.66 mills) or unincorporated St. Lucie County, outside both city limits.
- If you want the lower average insurance premium: St. Lucie County's Citizens averages are lower, $3,391 against $4,692 for HO-3.
- If you want a dock with no bridge to the inlet: look at Manatee Pocket, Port Salerno, Sailfish Point and the Crossroads in the Stuart area.
- If you want a newer home built to the 2007 code or later: western Port St. Lucie's master-planned areas are still building; in Tradition and Southern Grove, expect a CDD line and HOA dues.
- If you want no CDD: older Port St. Lucie neighborhoods usually have none, and none were identified in downtown Stuart; check every subdivision.
- If you want a lower sales tax: Martin County's is 6.5%, St. Lucie County's 7%.
- If you are selling and want a faster contract: Stuart city single-family homes went under contract in a median 34 days in September 2026; St. Lucie County's median was 52.
Before you choose
Compare two real homes, not two cities. Read the Stuart guide, the moving to Port St. Lucie page, the Port St. Lucie cost of living numbers, closing costs for Florida buyers and, for a first purchase, first-time home buyer steps. Nearby choices are in the Hobe Sound and Hutchinson Island guides.
Choosing between the two?
Get two real homes' monthly costs in writing
- Each home's value from 3 closed sales and 3 active listings
- Taxes after the reset, HOA, CDD and insurance beside the price
- Free. No obligation to list or buy, now or later.
Brent Sharp, Broker / Owner
Call or text (772) 272-9571 Get My Sharp Number Text Brent
The Sharp Number is a broker's opinion of value, not an appraisal. The request form opens on our homepage. Licensed Florida real estate brokerage, DBPR license CQ1051669. Port St. Lucie, FL.
Questions people ask about Port St. Lucie vs Stuart
Is Port St. Lucie or Stuart cheaper to buy in?
By Zillow's typical home value for September 2026 they are close: $384,099 in Port St. Lucie and $374,216 in Stuart. The monthly cost differs more than the price.
Are property taxes higher in Port St. Lucie or Stuart?
Port St. Lucie's 2026 proposed total is 22.0043 mills, against 17.1323 in the City of Stuart and 15.41 to 15.66 in unincorporated Martin County. On a $450,000 homesteaded home under 2026 rules, that is about $8,936 a year in Port St. Lucie and $6,958 in the City of Stuart, before flat fees (our arithmetic).
Is homeowners insurance cheaper in St. Lucie County or Martin County?
By Citizens' approved 2026 averages, St. Lucie County is lower: $3,391 for a homeowners (HO-3) policy against $4,692 in Martin County. Those are averages, not quotes.
What does a $450,000 home cost per month in Port St. Lucie vs Stuart?
Our estimate with 20% down at 7.11%, a homestead and 2026 tax rates: about $3,505 a month in Port St. Lucie, about $3,393 in the City of Stuart and about $3,373 to $3,381 in unincorporated Martin County, before HOA, CDD, flood insurance and any Stuart city fees. It is an example, not a quote.
Is there a Brightline station in Port St. Lucie or Stuart?
No. The Treasure Coast station site is downtown Stuart, but it is not funded or under construction after federal grants passed it over in August 2026, and no St. Lucie County station proposal was found.
Which has more flood risk, Port St. Lucie or Stuart?
It depends on the address, not the city. About 4.9% of St. Lucie County's residential structures are in FEMA's high-risk flood zone. Look up the zone by address. In both counties Citizens requires flood coverage on policies with wind from January 1, 2027.
What is the sales tax in Port St. Lucie and Stuart?
7% in St. Lucie County and 6.5% in Martin County in 2026: Florida's 6% plus a 1% St. Lucie surtax or a 0.5% Martin surtax (Florida Department of Revenue, form DR-15DSS).
Can I keep a boat with ocean access in Port St. Lucie or Stuart?
Most Port St. Lucie canals are freshwater drainage canals behind control structures with no lock, so only the tidal North Fork, its creeks and C-24 below S-49 reach the inlets, under 65-foot fixed bridges. In the Stuart area, Manatee Pocket, Port Salerno, Sailfish Point and the Crossroads have no bridge between the dock and the St. Lucie Inlet.
Do you help buyers and sellers in both Port St. Lucie and Stuart?
Yes. Brent Sharp, broker and owner of Sharp Real Estate Group LLC, helps people buy and sell homes across St. Lucie and Martin County Call or text (772) 272-9571.
Sources
- U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 city population estimates (July 1, 2025); University of Florida BEBR, April 1, 2025 estimate for Stuart.
- Zillow, Zillow Home Value Index, city level, September 2026 (Port St. Lucie, downloaded November 5, 2026) and Stuart home values, updated September 30, 2026. Model estimates, not sale prices.
- Redfin, Port St. Lucie and Stuart housing markets, three months ending September 2026. Read October 20, 2026.
- Florida Realtors, Monthly Market Detail, September 2026, Single-Family Homes, St. Lucie County and Martin County, published by Miami Realtors October 16, 2026; City and ZIP Code table, September 2026.
- St. Lucie County Property Appraiser, 2026 proposed taxing authority rates (Port St. Lucie 22.0043; school 6.2450; unincorporated 18.8075 to 18.9427); City of Port St. Lucie, final millage adoption, September 29, 2026, and FY 2026/27 Budget in Brief (stormwater $195); WQCS, August 31, 2026 (solid waste $482.16).
- Martin County Property Appraiser, 2026 Taxing Districts Final Millage Rate Map, dated October 13, 2026 (not certified); Martin County School District, 2026 rate of 4.8770 adopted September 8, 2026; Martin County Solid Waste MSBU resolution ($444.69).
- Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 additional homestead exemption ($26,411); Discretionary Sales Surtax Information for Calendar Year 2026 (form DR-15DSS, R. 11/25: St. Lucie 1%, Martin 0.5%). Read November 17, 2026.
- Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey, 30-year fixed average of 7.11% for the week of November 12, 2026, from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. Read November 17, 2026. The payment is our arithmetic on a $360,000 loan.
- Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, 2026 Approved Rate Changes by County, flood requirement and inspections. The Florida Statutes, section 627.7011 (roof age) and section 689.302 (flood disclosure).
- FEMA, Community Rating System eligible communities, October 1, 2026; Martin County, Flood Protection; OpenFEMA structure counts for St. Lucie County (4.9% in the Special Flood Hazard Area); City of Port St. Lucie repetitive-loss areas; Census building permits for Port St. Lucie, 2002 to 2007.
- City of Port St. Lucie, water and sewer conversion rates, effective October 1, 2026; Martin County, Connect to Protect; City of Stuart, Utility Division; Tradition Community Development Districts, Budget 2026 to 2027.
- NOAA, United States Coast Pilot 4, 2026 edition, Chapter 10 and Chapter 12; South Florida Water Management District, Works of the District (C-23, C-24, C-25 structures).
- Interchange lists from FDOT-based exit lists for I-95 and Florida's Turnpike; Florida's Turnpike Enterprise, Midway Road interchange; City of Port St. Lucie, Jobs Express Terminal; Martin County, Brightline. Read October 20, 2026.
- Florida Division of Elections, November 3, 2026 General Election results (unofficial); The Florida Legislature, CS/HJR 1-F (2026), enrolled text.
- BeachesMLS active listings, as shown on Port St. Lucie and Stuart homes for sale, refreshed every 15 minutes. Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
General information, not tax, legal, insurance or lending advice. The monthly table is an example built from the dated figures above; get a loan estimate, an insurance quote and the tax district for the actual address before you rely on any number here.
Last updated · Published November 17, 2026 · Reviewed by Brent Sharp, Broker