Hutchinson Island · Martin and St. Lucie County
Hutchinson Island, FL: which county, what a condo needs, and what to check before you buy or sell.
Short answer. Martin County holds the south end of Hutchinson Island, where A1A is NE Ocean Boulevard; St. Lucie County holds the rest, where it is S Ocean Drive. South Beach, by the Fort Pierce Inlet, is inside the City of Fort Pierce; most of the rest is unincorporated. Most homes are condos, and in buildings of three or more stories the price now runs through the milestone inspection and the structural integrity reserve study (SIRS). I'm Brent Sharp, broker and owner: 26 years helping people buy and sell homes here, 12,000+ homes valued, and I help buyers and sellers on both sides of the island. Call or text Sharp Real Estate Group LLC at (772) 272-9571.
The county line crosses the island and changes the tax rate, the building department and the evacuation map. Below: which part is which, condo prices, Florida's condo laws, insurance, flood, beaches and bridges.
Sharp Real Estate Group LLC · Free · No obligation to list · A broker's opinion of value, not an appraisal
Hutchinson Island, the numbers
Martin County Property Appraiser; Florida Realtors; Florida Statutes. Links in Sources.
Which county and which government is a Hutchinson Island address in?
The Fort Pierce Inlet splits the barrier island into North and South Hutchinson Island. Martin County holds the south end, St. Lucie County the rest, and the island continues north into Indian River County. The quickest test: A1A is NE Ocean Boulevard in Martin County and S Ocean Drive in St. Lucie County.
| Part of the island | County | City or unincorporated | ZIP codes | 2026 tax rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| North Hutchinson Island, north of the Fort Pierce Inlet | St. Lucie | Mostly unincorporated | 34949 | Unincorporated St. Lucie, 18.8075 to 18.9427 mills (proposed); confirm on the parcel |
| South Beach, just south of the Fort Pierce Inlet | St. Lucie | City of Fort Pierce | 34949 | Fort Pierce, 24.0293 mills (proposed) |
| South Hutchinson Island to the Martin line (S Ocean Drive) | St. Lucie | Unincorporated | 34949, 34957 | Unincorporated rates plus a 0.5200-mill South Hutchinson Island erosion levy |
| Martin County end (NE Ocean Boulevard, Sailfish Point) | Martin | Unincorporated | 34957, 34996 | 15.6581 mills (final map, not certified) |
The mailing address does not settle the county. Island Dunes (8600 and 8800 S Ocean Drive) and Dune Walk (7370 to 7380 S Ocean Drive) carry Jensen Beach addresses but are in St. Lucie County. Sailfish Point, Indian River Plantation, Hutchinson House, Suntide, Inlet Village and Ocean Terrace are on the Martin side. Check the parcel on the Martin County or St. Lucie County Property Appraiser first.
Building rules differ too. Martin County's growth plan caps buildings at four stories and 40 feet. Unincorporated St. Lucie island land falls under the county's Hutchinson Island Residential District and a building height overlay. The St. Lucie Nuclear Plant sits on South Hutchinson Island, about 10 miles southeast of Fort Pierce per the NRC.
What do Hutchinson Island condos and homes sell for?
No official price line covers just the island; its sales sit in ZIP codes that also cover mainland streets. The closest dated reads are below.
| Measure | Median | Other |
|---|---|---|
| ZIP 34996 condos, September (Florida Realtors); also covers Sewall's Point | $260K | 5 months of supply; 80% cash |
| ZIP 34957 condos, September (Florida Realtors); also covers mainland Jensen Beach | $468K (+20.0%) | 6 months of supply; 127 days to contract |
| ZIP 34949, all home types, 3 months to September (Redfin) | $385K (+12.1%) | 120 days on market; $291 per sq ft |
| ZIP 34949 listings, September (Realtor.com) | $469,750 asking (+1.6%) | 264 active; 110 median days |
| Hutchinson Island South, October (Realtor.com) | $467,500 sold | 96 days; 96% of list |
ZIP 34996 includes Sewall's Point and 34957 includes mainland Jensen Beach, so read those as the island plus its neighbors. Florida Realtors and Realtor.com figures are one month; Redfin is three months of all home types. Small samples swing.
The wider condo market is slow. In September 2026 St. Lucie County condos and townhouses had 7.8 months of supply and a median 117 days to contract; Martin County's had 5.1 months and 68 days, with condo medians below their 2023 levels.
What do milestone inspections and SIRS mean for a condo here?
Florida's 2022 to 2025 condo laws apply to every island building of three or more habitable stories:
Milestone inspection
Due by December 31 of the year the building turns 30, then every 10 years; a local building official may require it at 25 years based on factors including proximity to salt water (s. 553.899). St. Lucie County's page says 25 years for buildings within 3 miles of the coastline, for the unincorporated buildings it oversees. A phase 2 inspection follows if phase 1 finds substantial deterioration.
Structural integrity reserve study (SIRS)
At least every 10 years, covering roof, structure, fireproofing, plumbing, electrical, waterproofing and painting, windows and doors. Associations that existed in July 2022 had to finish the first one by December 31, 2025. Owner-controlled associations can no longer waive or reduce those reserves (s. 718.112).
2025 changes (HB 913)
Associations may fund SIRS reserves by special assessment, line of credit or loan, and may pause or reduce reserve contributions for up to two budgets after a milestone inspection, for budgets adopted through December 31, 2028.
Buyer's documents and 7 days
On a resale, the seller provides the declaration, bylaws, budget, financials, the milestone summary and the latest SIRS, and the buyer may cancel within 7 days, excluding weekends and holidays (s. 718.503).
Financing
Fannie Mae treats a project as ineligible with critical repairs, a failed mandatory structural inspection or unfunded repairs over $10,000 per unit due within 12 months, which pushes buyers toward cash.
Enforcement is real: CBS12 reported in July 2026 that a state OPPAGA report found 3 St. Lucie County buildings deemed unsafe or uninhabitable after 2024 phase 2 inspections, all vacated. Before you price or offer, get the milestone report, the SIRS and its funding plan, any special assessment, whether the board used the pause or a loan, and an HO-6 quote. Browse Hutchinson Island condos for sale.
What about insurance, flood and the coast?
- Condo unit insurance. Citizens' approved 2026 HO-6 averages: $1,547 in Martin County (down 8.8%) and $1,529 in St. Lucie County (down 9.2%). More in our Treasure Coast home insurance guide.
- Flood. From January 1, 2027 Citizens requires flood coverage on every policy with wind coverage, but condo unit-owner policies are exempt. Lenders still require flood coverage in FEMA Special Flood Hazard Areas. First Street's model, shown on Redfin, rates 97% of ZIP 34949 properties at severe flood risk over 30 years; that is a model, not a FEMA zone. Look up the zone by address on the FEMA Map Service Center.
- Coastal Construction Control Line. Seaward of the line, construction needs a state permit, and a seller of property partly or wholly seaward of it must give the statutory coastal disclosure at or before contract (s. 161.57).
- Erosion. Florida's June 2026 report lists 6.7 miles of northern Hutchinson Island in Martin County as critically eroded. Bathtub Beach has been renourished 13 times since 1999.
- Storms and evacuation. Hurricanes Frances and Jeanne both came ashore at the south end of Hutchinson Island in September 2004, three weeks apart. Martin County puts its barrier islands in evacuation zone AB; St. Lucie County uses zones A and B, with an address lookup on its emergency management site.
Which beaches and parks are on the island?
Martin County side: Stuart Beach (889 NE Ocean Boulevard), Bathtub Beach (1585 SE MacArthur Boulevard) and Jensen Beach (4191 NE Ocean Boulevard, at the causeway) are guarded county beaches. The House of Refuge, built in 1876, is the oldest building in Martin County.
St. Lucie County side: Pepper Park (3302 N A1A, 52 acres, lifeguards, nearshore reefs) and Fort Pierce Inlet State Park ($6 per vehicle) are on North Hutchinson Island. South of the inlet are Frederick Douglass Memorial Park (3600 S Ocean Drive, permitted beach horseback riding), Blind Creek (5460 S Ocean Drive, a 409-acre ocean-to-lagoon preserve) and Walton Rocks (6700 S Ocean Drive, an off-leash dog beach). See homes near Stuart Beach, near Bathtub Beach or near South Beach in Fort Pierce.
How do you get to the island, and where can a boat go?
By car: the Martin end is reached over the Evans Crary Bridge from Stuart to Sewall's Point and then the Ernest Lyons Bridge; the middle of the island over the Jensen Beach Causeway; and South Hutchinson Island from the north over the South Bridge in Fort Pierce.
By boat: NOAA's Coast Pilot lists fixed clearances of 65 feet at the Ernest Lyons Bridge (Intracoastal mile 984.9), 66 feet at the Jensen Beach Causeway (mile 981.4) and 65 feet at SR A1A in Fort Pierce (mile 965.8). Sailfish Point has no bridge between its docks and the St. Lucie Inlet, which NOAA calls "dangerous and particularly hazardous to small boats." No bridge crosses the Fort Pierce Inlet.
Who provides water and sewer?
On the Martin side, Martin County Utilities; its Rosewalk and Hutchinson Island grinder sewer project became available in 2022. On North Hutchinson Island, St. Lucie County's septic removal project is replacing about 530 septic tanks in the four neighborhoods still on septic. On South Hutchinson Island the provider was not confirmed in our sources, so ask the association and check the tax bill for any utility assessment.
Search Hutchinson Island by ZIP and building
By ZIP: 34949 (Fort Pierce beach ZIP, both islands) · 34957 (Jensen Beach, island and mainland) · 34996 (Stuart east, including the Martin end and Sewall's Point).
By building or community: Ocean Village · Harbour Isle at Hutchinson Island · Bryn Mawr Ocean Towers · Coral Cove Beach · Sea Pointe Towers · The Atrium on the Ocean · Sea Palms · Catamaran · Thumb Point · Mariner Bay · Hibiscus by the Sea · Ocean Harbour · Sailfish Point.
Buying or selling on Hutchinson Island?
Sellers: order the association's resale packet when you list, because buyers and their lenders read the milestone report, the SIRS and the budget before they read the listing remarks. Brent prices a unit against buildings with a similar inspection and reserve position. Start with a free written Sharp Number, a broker's opinion of value, not an appraisal.
Buyers: add the HO-6 quote, any special assessment and the association dues to the payment, then read property taxes after you buy and closing costs for Florida buyers. First home? See first-time home buyer steps. Comparing the mainland? Read the Stuart guide, Port St. Lucie vs Stuart or moving to Port St. Lucie.
Buying or selling on Hutchinson Island?
Get a written number for an island condo or home
- Priced against buildings with a similar milestone and reserve position
- Taxes, dues, assessments and HO-6 beside the price
- Free and written. No obligation to list
Brent Sharp, Broker / Owner
Call or text (772) 272-9571 Get My Sharp Number Text Brent
The Sharp Number is a broker's opinion of value, not an appraisal. The request form opens on our homepage. Licensed Florida real estate brokerage, DBPR license CQ1051669. Port St. Lucie, FL.
Questions people ask about Hutchinson Island
Is Hutchinson Island in Martin County or St. Lucie County?
Both. Martin County holds the south end and St. Lucie County the rest. On the island, A1A is NE Ocean Boulevard in Martin County and S Ocean Drive in St. Lucie County, so an S Ocean Drive address with a Jensen Beach 34957 mailing address is in St. Lucie County.
Which parts of Hutchinson Island are inside a city?
South Beach, just south of the Fort Pierce Inlet, is inside the City of Fort Pierce. The rest of South Hutchinson Island in St. Lucie County is unincorporated, the St. Lucie part of North Hutchinson Island is mostly unincorporated, and the Martin County end is unincorporated Martin County with its own tax district, 15.6581 mills in 2026.
What is a condo milestone inspection in Florida?
A structural inspection required for condo and co-op buildings of three or more habitable stories by December 31 of the year the building turns 30, then every 10 years (s. 553.899, Florida Statutes). A local building official may require it at 25 years.
What is a SIRS for a Florida condo?
A structural integrity reserve study: a study at least every 10 years, for buildings of three or more habitable stories, of the roof, structure, fireproofing, plumbing, electrical, waterproofing and painting, and windows and doors. Owner-controlled associations can no longer waive those reserves.
How long do I have to cancel a condo purchase in Florida?
On a resale, the buyer may cancel within 7 days, excluding weekends and holidays, after receiving the association documents the seller must provide, which include the milestone inspection summary and the latest SIRS (s. 718.503, Florida Statutes). HOA homes have a different 3-day rule.
How much is condo insurance on Hutchinson Island?
Citizens' approved 2026 averages for a condo unit-owner (HO-6) policy are $1,547 in Martin County and $1,529 in St. Lucie County. Those are Citizens averages, not market prices; quote the actual unit.
Do Hutchinson Island condo owners need flood insurance?
Lenders require flood coverage in FEMA Special Flood Hazard Areas. Citizens' rule requiring flood coverage on wind policies from January 1, 2027 exempts condo unit-owner (HO-6) policies, so check the building's flood zone and ask the association what flood coverage it carries.
What bridges go to Hutchinson Island?
From the south, the Ernest Lyons Bridge from Sewall's Point; in the middle, the Jensen Beach Causeway; to South Hutchinson Island from the north, the South Bridge in Fort Pierce.
Do you help buyers and sellers on Hutchinson Island?
Yes. Brent Sharp, broker and owner of Sharp Real Estate Group LLC, helps people buy and sell condos and homes on both the Martin and St. Lucie sides of Hutchinson Island. Call or text (772) 272-9571.
Sources
- Martin County Property Appraiser, 2026 Taxing Districts Final Millage Rate Map, dated October 13, 2026 (Unincorporated District One, Hutchinson Island, 15.6581). St. Lucie County Property Appraiser, 2026 proposed taxing authority rates (Fort Pierce 24.0293; unincorporated 18.8075 to 18.9427; South Hutchinson Island erosion MSTU 0.5200). Read October 20, 2026.
- Martin County and St. Lucie County community and county checks: Hutchinson Island (street names, ZIP codes) and Hutchinson Island South (2020 Census housing units); address checks with the U.S. Census Geocoder, October 20, 2026.
- St. Lucie County, Future Land Use Element, September 24, 2026 (Hutchinson Island Residential District, height overlay). Martin County, Comprehensive Growth Management Plan, Chapter 4 (four stories and 40 feet).
- Miami Realtors and Florida Realtors MLS data, Martin County and St. Lucie County City and ZIP Code, September 2026; Florida Realtors condo and townhouse detail reports for St. Lucie County and Martin County, September 2026.
- Redfin, ZIP 34949 housing market, three months ending September 2026; Realtor.com, inventory core metrics by ZIP, September 2026, and Hutchinson Island South overview. Read October 20, 2026.
- The Florida Statutes, section 553.899 (milestone inspections), section 718.112 (SIRS and reserves, as amended by HB 913, chapter 2025-175), section 718.503 (resale documents, 7 days) and section 161.57 (coastal disclosure).
- St. Lucie County, Milestone Inspections; DBPR, SIRS reporting; Fannie Mae, Selling Guide B4-2.1-03, August 5, 2026; CBS12, July 30, 2026.
- Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, 2026 Approved Rate Changes by County and flood requirement; Redfin ZIP 34949 page (First Street Flood Factor).
- Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Critically Eroded Beaches in Florida, June 2026; Martin County, Bathtub Beach; St. Lucie County, Fort Pierce Shore Protection Project; National Hurricane Center reports on Frances and Jeanne (2004); Martin County Evacuation Zones; St. Lucie County shelter and evacuation information.
- Martin County, Beaches; Historical Society of Martin County, House of Refuge and Elliott Museum; St. Lucie County, Beaches, Pepper Park and beach horseback riding; Florida State Parks, Fort Pierce Inlet State Park. Read October 20, 2026.
- NOAA, United States Coast Pilot 4, 2026 edition, Chapter 10 and Chapter 12, October 11, 2026 (bridge clearances, both inlets). NRC, St. Lucie Unit 1 (plant location).
- St. Lucie County, North Hutchinson Island Septic Removal Project; Martin County Utilities septic-to-sewer basin map, April 2025. Read October 20, 2026.
- BeachesMLS active listings, as shown on Hutchinson Island homes for sale, refreshed every 15 minutes. Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
General information, not legal, tax, insurance or lending advice. Condo law, rates and association budgets change; confirm each one for the building and unit before you rely on it.
Last updated · Published November 17, 2026 · Reviewed by Brent Sharp, Broker